James Gemmel was Professor of Economics and Business Education at Penn State and Director of the Business Education Department. The Gemmels were only briefly in their home as James left in 1960 to become President of Clarion State University. They apparently had tastes somewhat beyond their means. The house has a very elegant Continental style and is of impressive size, but a number of shortcuts were made, e.g., many unfinished block walls, not even a carport, and very poor insulation.
The next occupants were the Fred Nicholas family, who lived there for a number of years. Luckily Fred was an architectural engineer who probably saved the house from collapsing as well as sprucing it up, so perhaps the house should be renamed for them. The worst problem was the flat built-up roof, which leaked like a sieve. A neighbor recalls that Fred was always up on the roof. Fortunately, he was able to solve the problem.