Penn State Mark    Social Sciences Library

Scholarly Article Checklist

While sources are always a good indication of an article's reputability — for example, an article from Time will differ significantly than one from Mass Media Ethics — this checklist will help you to make this determination. An article with all or most of these components, and that is peer-reviewed, is considered "scholarly" by those in academia and in the field.

While not all articles may contain every component below, a scholarly article will contain most of them. With some practice you'll be able to distinguish the difference between popular articles and those better suited for scholarly use.

Scholarly Article Checklist
Does the article contain an Abstract?
What is an Abstract and what does it look like?
Does the article include references?
See an an example of different reference pages.
Does the article contain a Literature Review, Methodology section, or identifiable research premise?
Take a look at an article's formal sections.
Is the journal peer-reviewed?
What does it mean for a journal to be peer-reviewed? How will I know?
Text Only Version | Penn State Site Index | Privacy and Legal Statements | Copyright | ©2007 The Pennsylvania State University